smrtka69 @ Mon Mar 19, 2007 2:00 pm wrote:
Hello,
thanks for the reply anyways. I'm not very involved in the world of karaoke, I guess I misunderstood some things a bit, but you got it right what I wanted. Simply the original recording just without the voice, having separate tracks as recorded in the studio would be even greater.
But I'm possibly requesting way too much, although wouldn't expect it being impossible. I just hoped something like that would be available, however.
(I'd say that famous artists like Jamiroquai is will be recording in a highly professional studios and such a studio will probably archive a recording from someone like J. in separate tracks and when it comes to business...there are possibly many folks that would love being able to closely study the performance of those great musicians...)
As to the legal/illegal...I know, but still...law's law, humans are humans...err...don't wanna discus that here ok?
Cheers.
Technically, what you are saying is right, typically they do record the vocals on different tracks etc. So, does such recording exist? Yes. What are you chances of getting hold of such recording? You would have better chance of winning the lottery. (Maybe if you do win the lottery, you can buy the rights to the song and do it youself). First, the artists are very protective of their recording. They will never release the orginial recording in the form to anyone. Even if they can paid to release, such as for commercial purposes, they allow others to recreate the recording (such is the case with all karaoke recordings) or they will do a version that is specifically for the purpose.
Most of the time, it's not even artist's choice. I have a friend who recorded a couple of CDs that I am dying to trying to make it to CD+G format. I asked them and they don't even own the tape. If we pay the studio who recorded it a large sum of money, they can re-record without the lead vocal and give us a version of that. I am not about to thousands of dollars to just to those recordings. This is with the permission of thge original artists. Imagine trying to fight the reluctant artists to get to the original recording, in a word: impossible.
The legal issue, I won't even discuss it here.