I am not disputing who qualifies as a pirate and who does not. But there is a distinct difference in how it impacts different industries and even different companies within industries.
It's kind of like the flu. You can come in contact with the flu virus but it takes a certain amount of the flu virus to enter your system before it will have a negative impact on you. You can only absorb so much before you reach a tipping point and you are a miserable wreck.
The same holds true for piracy, Microsoft can absorb more than Latshaw. Sony can absorb more than a small independent (though it could be argued that piracy may raise awareness of the artists of said small independent label).
The fact is that piracy is theft. It doesn't matter if is increasing or decreasing, people are taking without compensating. Just because there are studies that say that piracy is decreasing or that pirates may buy more, doesn't discount that they are still stealing.
If only the local Safeway would let me steal Twix bares under the pretense that I will buy more later.
But it's not like the respective industries are just turning a blind eye to piracy. They are still very active in combatting it which has also been attributed to the increase in sales -
http://www.spin.com/articles/isohunt-se ... shut-down/-Chris