twansenne wrote:
Well if 1/2 the people are your core group singing odd songs, the only way to limit it is to politely ask/suggest they sing some more popular songs. Pick some good songs that you think your singers might be good at, and say "Hey John, Have you ever tried SONG X? I think your voice is perfect for it!"
If that doesn't work you will probably have to limit your "a collection larger than most KJs ". Having all those songs can bite you in the <span style=font-size:10px><i>(@$%&#!)</i></span>.
For several years now, I have very successfully culled the herd of obscure songs being sung, simply by removing them from the song books. It is amazing how many great songs get sung (songs the audience wants to here) when you remove the lesser known ones from the book. I will have to say that my books are a LOT smaller, but my singers find what they want to sing much quicker, and they actually get past the A's in the book.